My Love Letter

Video on Instagram​

Original Off-Broadway
​Cast Recording
Daddy Long Legs
Click Here

54Below  February 5, 2023
Northern Expsoure

Broadway’s biggest stars showcase the best of Canadian Musical Theatre. 

Click here for tickets 

Paul Alexander Nolan

Original Broadway Cast Recording

Click Here
 Amazon & iTunes

Paul joins the cast of PARADE on Broadway.

The acclaimed, sold-out New York City Center production of PARADE starring Tony, Grammy and Emmy Award® winner Ben Platt is moving to Broadway in the can’t-miss event of the year.

The New York Times hails it as a Critic’s Pick and “the best-sung musical in many a New York season. It recalls an era of big casts, big stories and big talent – a time when musicals actually felt like events.”

Show opens on February 21, 2023

Click here to learn more and get your tickets

other moments

Daddy Long Legs 

​​Photo: Jeremy Daniel

​Jesus Christ Superstar
​Photo by Joan Marcus



Original Broadway Cast Recording

Click Here
Download via all major platforms

Original Broadway
Cast Recording
​Bright Star
​Click Here


Dr. Zhivago​Photo: Matthew Murphy



Once​Photo by Joan Marcus


Escape to Margaritaville

​Photo by Matthew Murphy


Slave Play

​Photo by Matthew Murphy

Keely Hutton, Melanie O’Brien and Paul had the honor to perform a tribute to the life, legacy & incomparable talent of Brent Carver.
Learn more about the life of Brent.
Watch our video performing

“Try to Remember” from the benefit broadcast for the Performance Arts Lodge (PAL) Stratford charity in Stratford, Ontario.

​​​Jimmy Ray
Bright Star

​​​Photo by Joan Marcus

Original Broadway

Cast Recording
​Doctor Zhivago
Click Here

After a sold-out run at New York City Center under the direction of  Jason Robert Brown and Alfred Uhry, Paul will join the cast again as Hugh Dorsey in the Broadway show.

Paul has a vibrant history on Broadway that started with his debut in Jesus Christ Superstar. 

His credits include the world premier of the musical KNOXVILLE at Asolo Repertory.​

Paul was in the title role of Tully Mars on Broadway in the new musical Escape to Margaritaville in 2018. Paul has been seen as Billy Flynn in Chicago, one of the longest running musicals on Broadway in American history.

He was in the 2016 original Broadway musical Bright Star. The musical was a five time Tony Award nominee, including Best Musical by Steve Martin and Edie Brickell under the direction of Walter Bobbie. Paul earned a 2016 Drama Desk Award Nominee for Best Feature Actor for Bright Star.

Paul was in Once on Broadway. In 2015 he received Outer Critic Awards Nominee as Best Feature Actor in the Broadway musical - Doctor Zhivago.

Appeared in the Off-Broadway debut of the musical Daddy Long Legs and can be heard on the cast recording.

His television credits include: The Code, Madam Secretary and Instinct. He shot the indie film, The Scottish Play.

His additional credits include The Who's Tommy, West Side Story and As You Like It at the Stratford Festival and the world premiere of the rock musical Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots.